Review: Great Jones The Dutchess
More than any appliance or gadget you’ve got in your kitchen, the dutch oven is your workhorse because its versatility makes it perfect for a myriad of cooking tasks. Soup, stew, broth, jam, jelly, bread - you name it, you can make it in a dutch oven. In fact, if you buy nothing else for your kitchen, let the one thing you do splurge on be a dutch oven…and maybe a rubber spatula or two.
I remember the day I first got one, during a routine trip to Marshall’s on Boylston Street in Boston when I wasn’t ready for a long T ride home. It was in October, and around that time every year, as the leaves begin to change and the chill starts to set in, the store switches over from summer offerings to fall fare, complete with ornately-painted plates and charming autumn holiday tchotchkes. It’s all adorable and somewhat unnecessary, but what caught my eye that year was the Cuisinart dutch oven placed front and center on a table in the home section. My interest in food had by that time developed into a passion, and I was watching every cooking show and tutorial I could get my hands on. In many videos, the host had a dutch oven either in front of them or on display on an open shelf in the background. Of course, with massive budgets and the justification for such an expense, the dutch ovens I saw were top-of-the-line Le Creuset, always in perfect condition. Le Creuset dutch ovens are gorgeous enameled cast iron pots, made in France, with brightly-colored exteriors and cream-colored interiors. They’re meant to last you a lifetime, but lifetime-quality ain’t cheap - a brand new 6-quart Le Creuset dutch oven will set you back almost $400.
Still, the 5-quart dutch oven at Marshall’s that fall day was just as beautiful, and with a $60 price tag - a far cry from $400 - I just couldn’t help myself. So that little oven, with its glossy maroon exterior and sturdy body went home with me. Seven years later, my go-to pot, which looks pretty close to brand new thanks to meticulous upkeep, is still going strong. But with a smaller body and temperature limitations (I can’t cook anything past medium on the stove and 350 degrees Fahrenheit in the oven) it’s time for an upgrade. So, meet my new love, The Dutchess by Great Jones.
If you’re unfamiliar with Great Jones, it is a direct-to-customer cookware company that was founded in 2017 by Sierra Tishgart and Maddy Moelis, childhood best friends who set out on a mission to make quality cookware that’s not only aesthetically-pleasing, but offered at an affordable price point. With so many DTC cookware companies saturating the market at the moment, it can be hard for any brand to set themselves apart, but Great Jones has a not-so-secret weapon that blows everyone else out of the water: The Dutchess.
Designed to rival high-end brands like Le Creuset and Staub, The Dutchess is 6 3/4 quarts of enameled cast iron with a smooth coating on the inside and thrice-fired matte enamel finish on the outside. It’s currently available in 7 colors, and retails for $155.
What I love:
Sturdiness: This thing has HEFT! At 15 pounds it’s not the lightest pot out there, but I feel confident that it’s sturdy enough to withstand any cooking project I throw at it.
Size and shape: With its unique oval shape and nearly 7-quart volume, The Dutchess’ size is great for making big batches of stews as well as roasting large cuts of meat, and baking bread. The website even says that it’s big enough to roast an entire chicken!
Price: While $155 is still a lot to spend on one kitchen item, it is massively more affordable than higher-end dutch ovens with the exact same capabilities.
Color selection: My first introduction to The Dutchess was via Instagram when a large, pink dutch oven in a photo caught my eye. I wasn’t familiar with the logo, but based on the color I knew I had to learn more. Sadly, the pink color has been discontinued, but there are still several brilliant colors to choose from! When making my selection, I vacillated between the red (Marinara), and green (Broccoli) before ultimately deciding on yellow (Mustard). As soon as I opened the box I knew I’d made the right decision!
Interior color: When making jams, sauces, or even browning butter, it’s important to be able to see what you’re doing to ensure you don’t end up with a burnt mess. Some brands, like Staub, sell dutch ovens with cast iron interiors. That’s perfectly fine for soups and bread, but not ideal for other tasks in which the food might blend in. Le Creuset sells dutch ovens with cream-colored enamel interiors that make it easy to see, but after extended use, the inside tends to discolor. The Dutchess offers the best of both worlds: a gray interior that’s light enough for proper color detection and dark enough to hide slight discoloration.
High oven temperature tolerance: One major setback of my old Cuisinart is that I can’t cook anything in the oven past 350 degrees Fahrenheit. That means bread-baking is out, as well as finishing off dishes in the oven that require 375 degrees or higher. The Dutchess is oven-safe up to 500 degrees, and that is MARVELOUS.
Stove-top agnosticism: Whether you have a gas range, electric stove, or induction cook top, The Dutchess can be safely used. This is especially helpful if you move house and find yourself working with a new burner system.
What I don’t love:
Matte finish: One thing that bothered me right away was the matte finish on The Dutchess. All other dutch ovens I own or have looked at have a glossy finish that feels smooth to the touch. The matte finish on this oven feels slightly rough, and on more than one occasion, I’ve feared that any accidental slide on the gas range or bump from another pot on the stove is going to leave a huge scratch. So far, all marks have wiped off quickly and easily, but without the gloss, the outside has a bit of an “unfinished” look and feel.
Weight: As mentioned above, this dutch oven is HEAVY. The weight makes it feel sturdy, but carrying this thing around can be a bit of a struggle, and cleaning with one hand almost impossible. If you’re making a soup, make sure to use your ladle for as long as you can because it’s difficult to hold this pot with one hand while trying to scrape out food with the other for longer than a few seconds.
I’ve had The Dutchess for just over a month and have thoroughly enjoyed my time with it so far. Even with the heat off for long periods of time, my food has stayed piping hot, and clean-up has been a DREAM. Like any cookware, how well you take care of it will determine how long you’ll have it, but I can tell that this is a quality piece that will be with me through many of my future kitchen ups and downs. And did I mention that I love the color? Yellow is the happiest hue on Earth, so even if you’ve burned that stew to the point of no return, at least the sunny color will put a smile on your face!
Learn more about The Dutchess by Great Jones HERE!
